Trade Study Report: Fixed vs. Variable LGS Asterism
Trade Study Report: Fixed vs. Variable LGS Asterism V. Velur Caltech Optical Observatories Pasadena, CA Outline Introduction Assumptions Observing scenarios and assumptions Narrow fields High red-shift galaxies (studied with d-IFU) Cost implications Optomechanical RTC
Conclusions Other issues raised by this trade study 2 Introduction NGAO point design retreat Identified the need for both narrow-field and wide-field asterism configurations Natural question: Should the point design have fixed or continuously variable asterism radius? WBS Dictionary Consider the cost/benefit of continually varying the LGS asterism radius vs. a fixed number of radii (e.g. 5", 25", 50"). Complete when LGS asterism requirements have been documented
Approach Evaluate the benefit based on WFE for two science cases (resource limited) Estimate cost impact at highest subsystem level (ballpark) 3 Assumptions 5 LGSs in a quincunx 3 NGSs randomly distributed Field of regard varies with observing scenario Two are TT sensors, one is a TTFA sensor Other assumptions (atmospheric turbulence, noise, laser return, etc.) per NGAO June 06 proposal
4 Observing Scenario I: Narrow fields Potential advantages of variable asterism radius Better tomographic correction of TT and TTFA stars provides better Strehl ratio on-axis for a given sky coverage Evaluation procedure 1. 2. 3.
Assume science target is on-axis (near central LGS) For various sky coverage values, optimize system performance to compare continuously variable and discrete (5, 25, 50) asterism radii WFE vs. (off axis) TT star magnitude is plotted for the case where the TT star is corrected using MOAO 6 10% sky coverage case QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. 7
40% sky coverage case QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. 8 60% sky coverage case QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. 9
Observing Scenario II: High red-shift galaxies Potential advantages of variable asterism radius Better tomographic (MOAO) correction of science target, assuming constant correction within the asterism and natural anisoplanatic fallout without Evaluation procedure 1. 2. 3.
Assume TT/TTFA field of regard is 30 arcsec and brightest TT is mV = 17 (this corresponds to 10% sky coverage). Vary the science target position between 0 and 150 from quincunx center Optimize system performance to compare continuously variable and discrete (5, 25, 50) asterism radii 10 High red-shift galaxies Continuous v. Discrete LGS Asterism Comparison 900 0 800
40 50 Asterism Radius [arcsec] 60 Radius [arcsec] 11 Example implementation for this study (assumes telecentricity) QuickTime and a
TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. 12 Optomechanical Implications Discrete asterism Requires HO WFS positioner that is repeatable upon asterism reconfiguration To change from a 5 to 50 arcsec quincunx we need 40 mm travel at the focal plane. Continuous asterism Requires HO WFS positioner with higher accuracy The accuracy of getting LGS spots on the HOWFS is a combination of the stage position and the amount of asterism deformation that we can tolerate The minimum error allocated for LGS asterism deformation in the NGAO proposal is 5
nm This corresponds to 0.1 arcsec change in radius of the entire asterism! The HO WFS positioner need only position to this accuracy2 This is ~70 micron accuracy over the necessary travel range. This assumes that the uplink tip/tilt (UTT) has 0.1 arcsec (Ball Aerospace has mirrors can provide 0.001 arcsec on sky) resolution on sky. This loose tolerance would enable us to position the HO WFS continuously without much difficulty. Stronger cost driver will probably be the required angular tolerances of matching the incoming beam 13 RTC Implications Discrete asterism
Requires reconstructors for the three asterisms, updated according to changing Cn2(h) Continuous asterism Requires reconstructors updated according to asterism radius and changing Cn2(h) Question is: How do you choose the asterism radius? Need some auxiliary process and/or measurement Differential cost for estimating, setting, logging, and perhaps defending the choice of radius and corresponding reconstructor unknown 14 Conclusions Continuously variable asterism
There is little performance benefit in narrow field performance There is significant performance benefit for d-IFU science when the mismatch between asterism and target radius exceeds 20 arcsec There is little cost overhead in optomechanical hardware Real-time and supervisory control software costs will dominate Software costs allowing, we should assume continuously variable asterism in the system design 15 Other important considerations There are many concerns pertaining to LGS HO
WFS focus requirements LGS (differential) defocus between the 5 beacons due to projection geometry LGS defocus due to global Na layer shifts LGS defocus due to Na layer density fluctuations. LGS HO WFS would benefit from a telecentric optical space Chief ray always parallel to the optical axis Would save us the job of registering each WFS to the DM as the asterism geometry changes 16 References 1. 2.
R. Dekany, Private communication R. Flicker , Private communication 17 Backup Slides HO WFS Positional Accuracy Tolerance: WFE as a result of LGS deformation corresponding to best condition narrow field case  WFE [nm] QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor
are needed to see this picture. Asterism radius [arcsec] (w/ perfect asterism corresponding to lowest error) 19 Stage costs QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. 5 ATS-1000 stages would be ideal for continuously variable asterism. 20
Newport stages QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. QuickTime and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. Depending on the WFS optical tolerances on the angle of the incoming beam, this could be as low as $10,000$20,000. The cost driver for the stages would be the WFSs angular sensitivity. 21
Story. One day Poseidon went to war with the Zeus and made lots of waves. Charybdis rode the waves to wherever they took her including land. When Charybdis washed onto land she took water with her and the land became...
Satan Is Busy. So we need to resist him even more. How Busy Is Satan? "Be sober, be vigilant; because your adversary the devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour." (1 Pet. 5:8) Satan Is...
Fundraising: Car wash and odd jobs letter Passports: Valid through Dec 2015 Upcoming dates/ meetings Questions/concerns Parent traveler meeting (Last 10 min) All information and slides are available at globalxpeditions.weebly.com Agenda Albrecht Stacy Albrecht Jason Benson Laura Garnett Jill Haley...
Go to uw.edu/brand/fonts. Download three fonts: Encode Sans, Uni Sans, Open Sans. You may need to close PowerPoint and re-open in order to access the fonts. All templates themes include these brand fonts. YOU WILL NEED TO INSTALL FONTS TO...
This adapter might be integrated into the motherboard or act as a separate device that connects to a PCI slot or perhaps a PC card slot or USB port. The wireless access point (WAP) acts as the central connecting device...
At Cielo, It pays to "Discover" The "Big Picture" ASU and Parent Volunteers Logistics Student Teacher Roles Student Teacher Procedures SAGAN Expectations of Students Resources Q & A Room "tour" Discovery Room The "Big Picture" A Science Museum in a...
Introduction. Operation and Maintenance (O&M) is a large contributor to the life-cycle cost of wind farms, therefore the prediction and optimization of maintenance activities provides a significant opportunity for life-cycle cost reduction.
Ready to download the document? Go ahead and hit continue!