Civil Liability - University of Minnesota Duluth

Civil Liability - University of Minnesota Duluth

Civil Liability Conditions and Defenses What is the connection between ethics and deviance and law enforcement operations? When police officers fail to perform their assigned duties, perform them negligently, or abuse their authority, the possibility of civil liability exits.

Key points: There are Real Suits, frivolous suits, nuisance suits, deeppocket suits Visibility and recent rise in court findings of police liability

Number of suits generally increasing and the dollar amount of pending suits increasing Civil liability is the companion to Criminal complaint

Litigation is one of the ways for controlling police behavior Most law suits involve assault, battery, false imprisonment, and malicious prosecution Basic formula for any lawsuit Existence of a legal duty owed by one

party to another An alleged breach of that duty Injury or loss resulting from that breach Parties to the Law Suit Plaintiff: citizen Defendant: officer, supervisor, administrator, entire departments and police academies generally a specific person is singled out to be named in the law suit as well

as others associated with the incident State Suits It is within the rights of all citizens to take legal action against persons whom they feel have wronged them. (Civil tort - a civil wrong in which the action of one person causes injury to the person or property of another in violation of a legal duty imposed by law)

Three Categories Intentional tort - use in police cases Negligence tort- used in police cases Strict liability tort - not used in police cases Intentional Tort False Arrest and False Imprisonment Assault and Battery

Wrongful Death Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress Assault & Battery Assault - usually defined as the intentional causing of an apprehension of harmful or offensive conduct; it is the attempt or threat, accompanied by the ability, to inflict bodily harm on another person - committed if an officer causes another person

to think he/she will be subjected to harmful or offensive contact Battery - the intentional infliction of a harmful or offensive body contact - given this broad definition, the potential for battery exists every time an officer applies force on a suspect or arrestee)

Difference - assault is generally menacing conduct that results in a persons fear of imminently receiving a battery, whereas battery involves unlawful, unwarranted or hostile touching, however slight - in some jurisdictions assault is attempted battery Negligence Tort

Negligent Operation of Motor Vehicle Negligent Failure to Protect Negligent Police Training Breach of Duty Proximate Cause

Damage or Injury Defenses for Suites Contributory Negligence Comparative Negligence Assumption of Risk Federal Suites Based on the premise that when police misbehave, it is often the citizens

rights under the Constitution that have been violated - Civil Rights Act of 1871 1893 Action Section 1983 of Title 42 of the U.S. Code - passed in the aftermath of the Civil War - The law originally passed Congress in 1871 and was known as the Ku Klux Klan law 1893 Action Conditions

Usually filed in Federal Court .Discovery procedures more liberal .Attorneys fees are recoverable by the prevailing plaintiff in accordance with the Attorneys Fees Act of 1976 .Recognizes that city, county, and state police officers take an oath to uphold and enforce the laws of their specific state, and much public confidence and trust is entrusted to them - consequently, the law prohibits the depravation of life, liberty, or property without due

process of law Monroe v Pape (1961) Case of brutality - crucial aspect to Section 1983 is that the infraction must have occurred while the officer was acting under the color of the law - this means that the police officer in question must have been on duty and acting within the scope of his/her

employment Elements of a Section 1983 Lawsuit The defendant must be acting under color of law There must e a violation of a constitutional or a federally protected right

Federal Officers Federal officers cannot be sued under Section 1983 but can be sued under one of two complaints Bivens action - basically a judicially created counterpart of the 1983 action suit and the Supreme Court has allowed federal officers (not the federal government) to be sued for constitutional violations that would otherwise be the subject of the 1983 suit against a state or local officer (comes from Bivens v. Six Unknown Federal Narcotics Agents (1971)

Tort against the United States under Federal Tort Claim Act - Federal Tort Claim Act - Defenses Absolute Immunity Quasi-judicial Immunity Qualified Immunity Absolute Immunity

Applies only to judges, prosecutors, legislators - except in the case of a police officers actions connected with the trial process - police can be tried in criminal court in the case of perjury Quasi-judicial Immunity Certain officers are immune if performing judicial-type functions but not when performing other functions

connected with their office - probation officer preparing a pre-sentence investigation report upon the order of a judge Qualified Immunity The immunity defense applies to an officials discretionary (optional) acts, meaning acts that require personal deliberation and judgement

Relates to the good faith defense - a public officer is exempt from liability if he/she can demonstrate that the actions taken were reasonable and performed in good faith within the scope of employment Probable Cause Only in cases of false arrest, false imprisonment, and illegal search and seizures, either under tort law or Section 1983 - means reasonable good faith belief

in the legality of the action taken - expectation is lower than the Fourth Amendment definition Note: when the facts and circumstances within the officers knowledge and of which they have reasonably trustworthy information are sufficient in themselves to warrant a man of reasonable caution in the belief that an offense has been or is being committed Good Faith

Used in Section 1983 and not available in all states for tort laws - means that the officer acted with honest intentions under the law (meaningfully lawful) and in the absence of fraud, deceit, collusion, or gross negligence Good Faith most likely to be upheld If the officer acted in accordance with agency rules and regulations

If the officer acted pursuant to a statute that is believed to be reasonably valid but is later declared unconstitutional If the officer acted in accordance with orders from a superior that are believed to be reasonably valid If the officer acted in accordance with advice from legal counsel, as long as the advice is believed to be reasonably valid Can Police Sue Back?

Officer may have to hire on attorney in a tort case Those being sued may not have the money to pay if the counter suit prevails Less expensive and more convenient to get back at the suspect in a criminal case Many officers feel that the harsh treatment they sometimes get from the public is part of police work and is therefore accepted without retaliation

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Proximity Sensor

    Proximity Sensor

    อ่านค่าบนหน้าจอ NXT. Light Sensor. Light Sensor ทำหน้าที่ตรวจจับความมืดและแสงสว่าง ... โดย Light Sensor จะวัดแสงโดยรอบของมันเท่านั้น ...
  • Activity: Great Brains of the Enlightenment

    Activity: Great Brains of the Enlightenment

    Great Brains of the Enlightenment. Gallery Walk. ... He believed that if people were left on their own (without a government) they would be happy and peaceful. He thought that society's institutions (like school, arts, the media, and government) brought...
  • Population Evolution - MS. SWISS AP BIOLOGY

    Population Evolution - MS. SWISS AP BIOLOGY

    Hardy Weinberg. Population: group of individuals of the same species, in the same area, that interbreed. Gene Pool: copies of every type of allele at every locus in all members of the population *Different from Punnett Squares- because we assume...
  • Get out one sheet of paper and write

    Get out one sheet of paper and write

    U.S. attitudes towards the Japanese - years of the "yellow peril" U.S. bans the sale of aviation fuel and scrap metal to the Japanese; reduces their oil supplies by 90%. The Dutch and French can't hold on to their Asian...
  • Cat breeds -

    Cat breeds -

    The cat's tongue is long and flat, with almost parallel sides. It tapers slightly in front and somewhat more in the back of the mouth. The upper surface of the tongue is covered with rasplike papillae which enable the cat...
  • ADEs EDFacts/Federal Reporting Overview An overview of the

    ADEs EDFacts/Federal Reporting Overview An overview of the

    WHAT IS EDFACTS?. U.S. Department of Education (USED) initiative to collect, analyze, report on and promote the use of high-quality, kindergarten through grade 12 performance data for use in education planning, policy making, and management and budget decision-making to improve...
  • The Lord Jesus Christ, Our Resurrected Savior

    The Lord Jesus Christ, Our Resurrected Savior

    To the cross intended for the sinner, murderer and seditionist, Barabbas, ("son of father") went the sinless, blameless and spotless Son of God the Father; Savior & Messiah, Jesus. Jesus went to the sinners' cross to die by crucifixion in...
  • Steven F. Ashby Center for Applied Scientific Computing Month ...

    Steven F. Ashby Center for Applied Scientific Computing Month ...

    Performance of a model may depend on other factors besides the learning algorithm: Class distribution Cost of misclassification Size of training and test sets Learning Curve Methods of Estimation Holdout Reserve 2/3 for training and 1/3 for testing Random subsampling...