Aristotle on Human Excellence

Aristotle on Human Excellence

Moral Theory Mark Pursley Issues in Moral Theory Do statements containing value terms have a truth value? If so, what are the truth conditions for value claims? Are relativist or

subjectivist accounts of moral language plausible? How does a community reach a consensus about moral issues? Virtue Theory Plato and Aristotle offer virtue theories of ethics. Virtue theories rely on an analogy between health (the good of the body) and eudaimonia

(the good of the mind). Aristotle on Human Excellence A virtue (arete, excellence) is a character trait, acquired by practice, that disposes a person to adopt the right course of action in morally charged situations. Virtues are lifeskills that enable a person to realize their potential for living the good life as a rational, social, animal. Are we not more likely to hit the mark if we have a target?

Good= the aim, end, or goal (telos) of an activity. What is the goal (final end) of living a human life? All agree: Happiness (eudaimonia, wellbeing, flourishing). What is happiness? Pleasure? No, too Brutish. Wealth? No, its a

means, not a final end. Honor? No, its not self-sufficient. Virtue? No, its not complete. The end sought must be final, self-sufficient, and complete. What is the function of human life? To find the human good, find the human function (ergon, what a thing does that makes it what it is). What is the characteristically human activity? Nutrition and growth? (No, all living things); Sensation? (No, all animals); Rational activity. Function of a good human: rational activity in accordance with virtue. [Objectors ask: Are evil people irrational?]

Becoming Excellent As a skill or craft, virtue is acquired by practice. Patterns of behavior produce states of character. Good character produces good behavior. If you imitate good people, youll become one. Moral virtues control natural feelings (passions, appetites) and actions, making

them arise in the right amounts at the right times for the right reasons (such a rule or principle as would arise in the mind of the practically wise person). Virtue: a mean between extremes Confidence, appetites, anger, giving $. Excess Mean Deficiency Foolhardiness Courage Cowardice Indulgence

Hot head Cool head Apathetic Too generous Generous Stingy Temperance Insensibility Character Types Heroic: extraordinary goodness. Virtuous: Takes

pleasure in doing good. Continent: Must control bodily desires in order to do good. Incontinent: Try's, but fails, to control bodily desires, and so does evil. Vicious: Takes pleasure in doing evil. Bestial: Subhumanly wicked.

Immanuel Kant ( 1724-1804) Defends a deontological approach to morality. Everyone must admit that if a law is to be morally validthen it must carry with it absolute necessity. The ground of obligation must be sought apriori in the concepts of pure reason. Kantian Ethics

Morality is a sacred duty, not a means to happiness. (A good will is more important than a good life.) Reason can discern the moral law. The will chooses which actions to perform. Inclination reflects how one feels about ones options. When reason (not inclination) directs the will, one does ones duty. The motive of duty. Acting from inclination or acting from duty. An action has moral worth if and only if it is done from the motive of duty. The prudent shopkeeper acts honestly because it is good policy. Such

acts have no moral worth. Nor do the kind acts of helpful people. The cold, uncaring person who helps others because duty commands it, has moral worth. Hypothetical imperative, if you want x, do Conditional. Categorical imperative: Unconditional commands. Do X! (Whether you like it or not.)

The Categorical Imperative Act only on a maxim which you could (at that time) will to become a universal law. Act as if the maxim of your action would instantly become a general law of nature. Maxim: I do action x in circumstances C to obtain end E. 1. Find the maxim; 2. Universalize; 3. Imagine the universalized maxim as a natural law; 4. Ask Is this a possible law of nature? 5. Ask Can one will this to be a law of nature? CI 3: Act so as to treat humanity (yourself and others) always as an end, never merely as a means. Consequentialism

Consequentialist theories hold that the goodness or badness of actions resides in the consequences those actions produce. J.S. Mills Utilitarianism is the leading theory. Mills Utilitarianism Greatest Happiness Principle: Actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to promote the reverse of happiness. Happiness is pleasure and freedom from pain. Unhappiness is pain and the privation of pleasure. Not an invitation to indulgence: A beasts pleasures do not satisfy a human

beings conception of happiness. Ways to Measure Pleasure: Quantity and Quality. Pleasure is not just a matter of quantity. Higher quality pleasures (like using ones mind, creativity, doing good deeds, having friends) are more desirable and make life more worth living than mere bodily sensations.

Aim of utilitarianism: An existence exempt as far as possible from pain, and as rich as possible in enjoyments, both in point of quantity and quality. Morality consists in the rules which, if followed, would secure this end for all sentients. Utilitarianism and Justice A standard objection to utilitarianism alleges that the theory will require the use of unjust means whenever doing so is likely to produce a greater balance of pleasure. This would permit a policy of

punishing the innocent to avert a riot, to deter wrongdoers, etc. Utilitarians may respond by pointing out that, in fact, no society which falsely accuses innocent citizens will promote a greater balance of pleasure in the long run. The greater good can only be attained in a society that upholds basic principles of justice (e.g.. the guilty are punished and the innocent acquitted). Alfred Jules Ayer 19101989 Language, Truth, and Logic. A defense of radical empiricism.

Logical Positivism Argues that metaphysical, theological, and moral propositions are meaningless. Ayers Critique of Utilitarianism Verificationism: An empirical hypothesis is significant (legitimate) only if some possible sense experience is relevant for determining its truth or falsity. Utilitarianism claims

actions are good if they produce pleasure or reduce pain. We cannot agree that to call an action right is to would cause...the greatest balance of pleasure...because it is not self-contradictory to say it is....wrong to perform the action that would...cause the greatest happiness. Ayers Emotivism

Since absolutist theories are unverifiable, and naturalistic theories violate linguistic convention, moral propositions are simply expressions of approval or disapproval. Adultery is wrong just means I disapprove of adultery, or Boo! adultery! Realist response: Moral propositions may express emotions but it is still legitimate to ask about the sorts of conditions that appropriately evoke approval or disapproval.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Fall Protection Susan Harwood Grant Training Program

    Fall Protection Susan Harwood Grant Training Program

    Fall Protection Paul Mangiafico OSHA Compliance Assistance Specialist Hartford Area Office Fall Protection Susan Harwood Grant Training Program * Some things should be painfully obvious Fall Protection Susan Harwood Grant Training Program * See interpretations for guidance Steep roof means...
  • Motivating People to Make Lifestyle Changes

    Motivating People to Make Lifestyle Changes

    Make Lifestyle Changes by Elaine Frank, M.Ed., RD Vice President American Institute for Preventive Medicine Methods for Increasing Motivation/Compliance Make materials easy to use Use feedback system Model and practice techniques Provide materials for techniques Dramatize the concept Make activities...
  • Statewide System of Support Foundational Services Illinois State

    Statewide System of Support Foundational Services Illinois State

    Kylene Beers makes an analogy we can all relate to in her book When Kids Can't Read, What Teachers Can Do. Here we have the "vocabulary casserole" which combines 20 unknown words, a typical dictionary, a weekly matching test and...
  • Overview and Status of the ATLAS Pixel Detector

    Overview and Status of the ATLAS Pixel Detector

    Claudia Gemme, CERN/INFN-Genova on behalf of the ATLAS Pixel Community 10th ICATPP Conference, Como, Oct 8th 2007 * * * * * * * ATLAS: A Toroidal LHC ApparatuS The ATLAS Pixel Detector The Pixel Detector is the innermost part...
  • Struggling with Religious Diversity

    Struggling with Religious Diversity

    struggling with religious diversity unit 2: day 4
  • PowerPoint - Carbohydrates

    PowerPoint - Carbohydrates

    Monosaccharide is a sugar with a single chemical unit. Glucose - mildly sweet sugar found in fruits, vegetables, honey and corn. Fructose - lightly sweet sugar found in fruits, many vegetables, and honey. Galactose - not very sweet sugar found...
  • Presentación de PowerPoint

    Presentación de PowerPoint

    Proponías una vuelta al pasado, a nuestra juventud, a redescubrir desde el presente como fueron aquellos meses pasados en las lejanas tierras saharianas, sobre todo con la perspectiva que dan los años y que permitían reflexionar mas serenamente como fue...
  • Whiplash Associated Disorder: The pathway from acute to ...

    Whiplash Associated Disorder: The pathway from acute to ...

    Jouko Kivioja, Irene Jensen, and Urban Lindgren. Neither the WAD-classification nor the Quebec Task Force follow-up regimen seems to be important for the outcome after a whiplash injury. A prospective study on 186 consecutive patients. Eur Spine J. 2008 Jul;...